By admin 
Hurricane season is here, and if you own a home in Forest Acres, Irmo, Lexington or anywhere else in the Midlands, you already know the drill.
Read more What are the odds the ice cream machine is down at your local SC McDonald’s? Take a look
The oaks and pines that make your yard beautiful are the same trees that can crash through a roof when a summer storm barrels through. And when the tree that lands on your house belongs to the neighbor, the question gets complicated fast.
Here’s what South Carolina law actually says about who pays.
Call your insurance company first
When a tree hits your house — yours or your neighbor’s — the first call goes to your insurance company. Not the neighbor. Not a lawyer. Your insurer.
That surprises a lot of homeowners, but it’s how the system works in most cases. Your homeowner’s policy is generally expected to cover the damage regardless of which side of the property line the tree grew on, according to SC Appleseed, a legal justice center that tracks how these disputes play out under state law.
The catch: this only holds if the damage was caused by what the law calls “natural causes” — commonly known as an “act of God” — and if your policy covers storm damage and hasn’t lapsed.
Before hurricane season gets any deeper, pull out your policy and read the fine print. Confirm that wind, falling trees and storm damage are all covered. Freak storms typically qualify as acts of God, but you need to be sure.
What the “act of God” doctrine actually means
This is the phrase that determines whether you can go after your neighbor — and in most storm cases, you can’t.
“As a general rule, compensation may not be obtained for losses, damage, or harm suffered as a result of an act of God, which means an occurrence due directly and exclusively to natural causes without human intervention and which no amount of foresight, pain, or care, reasonably exercised, could have prevented. This definition includes natural disasters,” experts from SC Appleseed said.
Translation for the average homeowner: if a healthy tree gets ripped out of your neighbor’s yard by hurricane-force winds and lands on your kitchen, that’s on your insurance. Your neighbor didn’t cause the storm, and they couldn’t reasonably have prevented a healthy tree from falling.
You’ll still pay your deductible. But you shouldn’t expect a check from next door.
Read more Road linking major Columbia thoroughfares targeted for repair after years of inaction
When your neighbor can be held liable
There’s an important exception, and this is where documentation matters.
The act of God defense only applies “where the natural disaster or similar act of God is the sole or exclusive cause of the damages.” If your neighbor knew a tree was diseased, dead or dangerously leaning and did nothing about it, courts have found that failure to take precautions contributes to the damage — meaning the storm wasn’t the sole cause.
In plain terms: a dead pine that any arborist would have flagged doesn’t get the same legal protection as a healthy oak. If your neighbor ignored an obvious hazard, they may be on the hook for repair costs.
This kind of claim is rare, and it’s not easy to prove. But it does happen.
How to document a neighbor’s negligent tree
If you can see a tree on a neighboring property that looks like trouble — dead limbs, a heavy lean toward your house, visible rot, fungus at the base, a trunk that’s split — start a paper trail now, before the next storm.
A few practical steps:
- Take dated photos of the tree from multiple angles. Cellphone metadata is your friend here.
- Note the date and put your concerns in writing. A polite text or email to your neighbor mentioning the tree creates a record that they were notified.
- Keep copies of any response — or lack of one.
- If the tree hangs over your property, you generally have the right to trim branches back to the property line. Check with an arborist before cutting anything substantial.
That documentation is what separates a losing insurance claim from a case where your neighbor’s carrier — not yours — ends up paying.
Coverage and deductible tips before the next storm
A few things worth checking on your policy right now:
Confirm your dwelling coverage reflects current rebuild costs. Construction prices in the Midlands have climbed, and a policy written five years ago may not cover today’s repair bills.
Look at your deductible. Some South Carolina policies carry separate — and higher — hurricane or named-storm deductibles. That’s the number that matters when a pine goes through your roof in August, not the general deductible on the front page.
Ask your agent specifically about tree removal. Some policies cover the cost of removing the tree from your house but cap what they’ll pay to haul away debris from the yard. That gap can run into thousands of dollars after a bad storm.
And if there’s a tree next door that’s making you nervous, don’t wait for the wind to make the decision for you. A conversation now — followed by a photo and a text — is a lot cheaper than a lawsuit later.
This report was produced with the assistance of a proprietary tool powered by artificial intelligence and using our own originally reported, written and published content. It was reviewed and edited by our journalists.
Read more ‘Like out of a movie.’ Eric Bieniemy neighbor describes police response to shooting