How did Lexington County Dems flip GOP leader’s State House seat?

Greg Green was grinning ear to ear when he addressed Lexington County’s Democrats this week.

Read more Two shooters of Scott Spivey now face murder charges. Here’s what we know

“This feels really good,” the party’s county chairman said to cheers and applause from about 50 people gathered in a meeting room of the Lexington public library on Monday.

Often shut out of politics in the Republican-dominated county, Democrats rode the “blue wave” of increased turnout to run closer in state legislative races in 2026, capped by engineer Joe Madge’s nail-biting win over longtime GOP Rep. Micah Caskey in District 89.

Madge told Monday’s gathering that turnout was the key to winning one of the closest, and more surprising, results from election night.

“I knew the Democratic base was about 40 to 45%, so if we could move it, I knew we could move the dial,” Madge said to The State. “Republican turnout was good, it was about at normal midterm level, but we had presidential level turnout.”

That shows up at the precinct level, where 11 out of 19 precincts in the Cayce-West Columbia based district were carried by Madge. He flipped eight, including many in the core of the two cities plus Saluda River, Leaphart Road and Chalk Hill in the Dixiana area. Along with the Irmo precincts, those were some of the strongest Democratic areas in the county.

Caskey had only just been chosen as House Republicans’ new majority leader ahead of his 106-vote loss to Madge, which was one of the closest State House races in the state and required a recount to confirm.

Caskey’s status boosted the profile of Madge’s win, one to 10 races statewide where Democrats flipped GOP-held seats in the S.C. House of Representatives.

“We didn’t set out to knock out party leadership, that’s just what happened,” Madge said.

Even in the year of the “blue wave” that lifted Democrats to wins in conservative territory elsewhere — including Democrat Annie Andrews’ statewide U.S. Senate victory and former Navy Vice Admiral Nancy Lacore’s narrow win in South Carolina’s 1st Congressional District — Caskey admits he didn’t foresee a close race in House District 89.

“It obviously is a change from recent voting patterns,” said Caskey, who carried the district in 2024 by more than 20 percentage points, or almost 3,500 votes. “We didn’t see any indication that this sort of change was on the horizon.”

Caskey did his own analysis of the election results, and while about 2,500 fewer votes were cast this year compared to two years ago — a not unusual drop off from a presidential election year to a midterm — the Republican pulled around 3,000 fewer votes even as his Democratic opponent garnered almost 600 more, enough to narrowly flip the seat.

Madge said he worked to maximize his exposure to voters as a first-time candidate.

“We really put the work in,” he said. “I really did focus on meeting voters face-to-face at the door. As a first-time candidate, that’s the only way you’re going to get known.”

Read more Susan Smith, who drowned her children, makes bid for parole at Thursday hearing

He estimates he and his campaign team spoke knocked on 12,000 doors, in addition to 9,600 phone calls, 34,000 text messages and 2,000 handwritten post cards. The campaign even managed to get up a couple of billboards and spent money on radio ads in the final weeks before Election Day.

“There are people who don’t answer their phone, who don’t look at text messages, so you’ve got to do all of the things to reach the voters,” he said.

Caskey said he doesn’t believe there’s suddenly been a major demographic shift in Cayce and West Columbia that could explain his defeat.

“People can change their minds. Opinions can change,” Caskey said. “I don’t know how you pick which were previously Caskey voters that were turned off for whatever reason, but that’s 3,000 less voters for the Republican candidate. Even if the increase [in Madge’s voters] is previous Republican voters, there’s still 2,400 people who don’t appear in this election. That tells me we had a problem with getting out the vote… I didn’t do enough right to motivate those people to come out.”

A similar pattern played out at the congressional level. U.S. Rep. Joe Wilson, R-Springdale, won 68,000 votes in Lexington County, down 30,000 votes from 2024. Meanwhile, his Democratic challenger Zyon Khalifa increased the total Democratic number of votes in the county by almost 1,000 votes in a non-presidential year. That helped move the 2nd District from a near 20-point Republican win to a less than 1% victory following a recount.

Caskey said he had nothing but good wishes for his opponent, who he said he hadn’t spoken to or interacted with on the campaign trail until he called him to congratulate him on his victory.

“I think he will do the best that he can, I have no doubt,” Caskey said.

The former majority leader, meanwhile, is still considering what his future in politics may look like.

“My passion for helping people is unchanged, so I’ll look at everything and see what makes sense. It will depend on a lot of things,” Caskey said.

To his former House colleagues, he said, “Just keep working hard and keep focused on the people who sent them to the House.”

Madge said he wants to focus on affordability and cost of living once he gets to the State House, and believes those are issues where Democrats can find common ground with the Republican majority.

”They have factions in their own party, so they’re going to have to work with Democrats,” he said. “I hope I’m not naive, but I would think it would help Republicans to do something to help their constituents.”

Now as he heads into freshman orientation, Madge hopes he can apply lessons from his campaign to other Democrats who came close to winning in Tuesday’s election, especially the importance of getting out the vote.

Read more South Florida pastor found guilty on all counts in Haiti president assassination

“Every vote matters,” Madge said. “It mattered in my election.”

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *