‘People were looking under their own beds’: A film revisits a 1955 hunt for gay men in Idaho

In the 1950s, Boise, Idaho, was a wholesome, family-friendly place — a haven of “immaculate respectability.”

Read more Weekend Crime Watch: ‘Taken: Natalee Holloway,’ ‘OJ’s Accomplice’ and 4 more to binge Nov. 20-22

At least, that was how many perceived it — until 1955, when the city of trees was “shaken to its roots” by scandal: a far-reaching investigation outing gay men in the community and accusing them of pedophilia.

So begins The Fall of ‘55, a 2006 documentary about the investigation and prosecutions of these men. That year, a juvenile probation officer learned that some teenage boys had earned money in exchange for sexual favors with men in the community — and announced that there was a “widespread sex ring” of men preying on teenage boys, Director Seth Randal told the Idaho Statesman.

There was, in fact, no sex ring. When police exhausted the “handful of men” who had engaged in sexual acts with teenagers, they “started going after consenting adults,” said Randal, who grew up in Nampa and first learned about the episode in high school.

“The community reaction became very inflamed,” Randal said. “It became what a lot of people would categorize as a witch hunt.”

Things got so extreme that men avoided walking down the street together because people might think they were gay, one speaker in the film recalls. It got to the point where “people were looking under their own beds” trying to root out gay men, another speaker said.

The film’s 2006 premiere filled The Egyptian Theatre in downtown Boise to standing room only — and had to turn away about 100 people, Randal said.

Twenty years on from the film’s premiere, acceptance of the gay community has increased in many ways, the film’s creators told the Statesman.

“The Secretary of the Treasury is a married gay man in the Trump administration,” said Alan Virta, an archivist who served as the film’s historical advisor.

But treatment of the trans community — nationwide and in Idaho — makes Randal feel the film is “more relevant than ever,” he said.

Read more Halloween party spiraled into stabbings and gunfire. A 17-year-old is charged with murder

The Idaho Legislature has been prolific in writing bills targeting the community: barring trans women from women’s sports and restrooms, banning them from changing the listed sex on legal documents, and barring teachers from referring to students by pronouns different from their sex assigned at birth.

These days, though gay people may be less of an “out-group,” said Michael Guillén, a reporter who has covered the film since its inception, they’ve been replaced by the trans community.

“It adds a very funny thing in my mind,” Guillén said. “Like, what has the achievement actually been if we’re actually kind of in the same place, only with a different set of victims?”

One of the biggest takeaways of the film, creators said, is the lasting trauma of this chapter of Boise’s history for the men affected — and for their families. One man’s family fled the country after he was outed, Randal said.

Another man, who’d been prosecuted and had since moved to New York, seemed eager to do an interview with Randal’s team, Randal recalled. But the next day, Randal got a call from his sister, who still lived in Boise.

“ ‘Don’t ever call my brother again. You leave him alone,’ ” he recalls her saying. He realized that, even decades later, the scars were fresh, he said.

Guillén, who grew up in Twin Falls, first learned about the scandal when he was in high school. Reading a 1966 book about the episode, called The Boys of Boise, he was struck by “the ability of blackmail to destroy the lives of people,” he said.

In the 1970s, the gay community nationwide was increasingly coming out into the open, he said. Guillén, who is gay, moved to San Francisco, seeking to join it.

“I told myself, ‘You will never be blackmailed,’ “ he recalled. “ ‘The only way you can be blackmailed is if you are not honest about who you are.’ ”

Read more Traffic shut down amid Highway 321 standoff between SC man and police chief

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *