After bruising SC election year, does Ralph Norman have a future in politics?

U.S. Rep. Ralph Norman has made a political career out of betting on himself, often by walking away from something secure in pursuit of something larger.

Read more SC Democrats set their presidential primary date. When will GOP contest happen?

Twenty years ago, Norman gave up a seat in the South Carolina House to challenge longtime Democratic U.S. Rep. John Spratt. He lost by nearly 14 percentage points then returned to state politics. A decade later, he left the Statehouse again to run for Congress, survived a Republican runoff by just 221 votes and went on to spend nearly a decade representing South Carolina’s 5th Congressional District.

This year, Norman made his biggest gamble yet. He gave up a safe congressional seat, spent millions of his own dollars and ran for governor. He finished third. Weeks later, the sudden death of U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham created another opening, and Norman jumped almost immediately into a second statewide campaign.

On Tuesday, South Carolina voters handed him another loss, choosing Darline Graham, who was appointed to finish her brother’s expiring term, by about 5 percentage points in the Republican runoff.

Whether that defeat marks a political end for Norman is harder to say. The 73-year-old has lost before and found his way back, and the people who know him best describe someone who rarely interprets a setback as an instruction to stop.

“He’s absolutely a risk-taker,” said Mark Piland, who spent more than six years as Norman’s congressional chief of staff and remains close with him. “Not even measured risk.”

If Norman believes something is right, Piland said, he pursues it without dwelling on what it might cost him. When things did not go his way, Piland said Norman tries to understand what caused a legislative loss, then “re-attack it in a different way” rather than dwell on the setback.

“It was always like, well, on to the next battle,” Piland said. “If it costs him a seat, it costs him a seat… That’s just the way he thinks.” 

‘An outsider who worked his way on the inside’

That instinct helped produce one of the central contradictions of Norman’s life. He has spent two decades cultivating the politics of an outsider even as politics became his career. He is a millionaire real estate developer who casts himself against elites; a longtime officeholder who rails against the establishment; a conservative who stood by Nikki Haley over President Donald Trump in the 2024 presidential primary, and who then spent this summer insisting he remained firmly aligned with Trump’s agenda.

The contradictions rarely seemed to bother Norman.

Scott Huffmon, a Winthrop University political science professor who has followed Norman’s career, said calling him a political outsider after decades in elected office is inaccurate. But Norman has continued to function as something different – a party outsider positioning himself against the Republican mainstream and arguing that other Republicans are too moderate or too willing to compromise.

That reputation followed him to Washington. Piland said House Republican leaders could not simply assume Norman would support major legislation. On significant votes, Norman was often called into the speaker’s office so leadership could find out what changes he wanted and whether he would ultimately come aboard.

“He was in the middle of every major decision,” Piland said.

Chad Connelly, a former South Carolina Republican Party chairman, has been friends with Norman for years. Connelly ran against him for Congress in 2017 before endorsing him in the runoff, and described Norman as “an outsider who worked his way on the inside.”

His family’s real estate business made him wealthy enough to put large sums of his own money into his political ambitions allowing him to argue that he is less dependent on donors or party institutions than many candidates. Huffmon said that financial independence can reinforce the outsider pitch when Norman uses it to cast himself as less beholden to outside interests.

In his concession speech Tuesday, Norman pointed to roughly $8 million in spending against him. He contrasted that with money his campaign raised in South Carolina or drew from his own pocket and criticized outside PAC money that helped Graham, including funding he attributed to Democrats. 

Beyond helping fund his campaigns, Connelly sees Norman’s business background as a possible explanation for his comfort with political risk. Development, he said, requires putting money and reputation on the line without knowing whether the investment will pay off. He described it as a “big risk, big reward” mentality and said Norman’s years in business may have made the possibility of losing feel less disqualifying than it would to a more cautious politician.

Piland offered a less ideological and more personal picture. He remembers Saturday mornings when staffers would wake to text messages from Norman after he had encountered someone at a farmers market with a problem involving the federal government. Norman sent over the person’s name and number and told the staff to see what they could do, even when aides were not sure the problem was something a congressional office could solve.

“My gosh, he kept pushing,” Piland said.

Piland said a constituent message once slipped through the office’s correspondence system without a response. Norman found out, and the episode prompted the office to reconfigure its process to make sure every constituent heard back. Piland said it was the angriest he ever saw him.

Read more Here are some of the SC residents — and animals — who hold Guinness World Records

That loyalty was evident Tuesday. Norman lost statewide, but voters in the parts of South Carolina where he built his strongest base stayed with him. He won Greenville County with about 67% of the vote and Spartanburg County with about 66%, while taking his home York County by nearly a two-to-one margin.

Trump endorsement

Tuesday’s runoff tested Norman’s anti-establishment conservative base against Trump’s intervention in the race.

Norman entered the runoff with months of statewide campaigning behind him and a conservative grassroots following that helped carry him out of a crowded first round. But Trump endorsed Graham and traveled to South Carolina days before the runoff to rally with her.

That endorsement left Norman in the position of asking voters to trust him to advance Trump’s agenda, while also asking them to disregard Trump’s judgment about who should do it.

Huffmon said the result answered uncertainty surrounding Trump’s influence in the state after his preferred candidate lost the gubernatorial primary earlier in the summer. Turnout increased in the runoff, Graham expanded her geographic support and Norman remained strongest in the areas that formed the core of his coalition.

“He made this a referendum about himself,” Huffmon said of Trump.

Tension with Trump predates this race. Norman endorsed Nikki Haley over Trump in the 2024 presidential primary, but during both of his statewide campaigns this year repeatedly emphasized his support for Trump’s agenda. After losing the governor’s primary, Norman said he was disappointed Trump had intervened in a state race. But when he launched his Senate bid, Norman said he called Trump and asked for his endorsement. 

Even in defeat, Norman tried to separate the president from the president’s decision.

“The president got involved. He has that right. That’s his prerogative,” Norman told supporters Tuesday, adding that Trump’s policies were good but that he “never understood why he got in this race.”

The mention of Trump drew boos.

Trump was less conciliatory. In a Truth Social post Wednesday, he said Norman “ruined his career when he endorsed Nikki Haley.”

What’s next for Norman?

Now Norman is left, for the first time in years, without an elected office waiting for him.

After losing the governor’s primary in June, Norman had already begun planning for life after elected office. He announced plans for a conservative watchdog group, the Legislative Accountability Institute of South Carolina, which he said would track lawmakers’ votes, scrutinize government spending and recruit challengers to Republicans he believed had strayed from conservative principles.

“I’m not going to stay silent,” Norman said at the time. “I will not stop exposing those who put political power ahead of conservative values.”

Neither Piland nor Huffmon was willing to call Tuesday’s loss the end of his political life. Piland said Norman may welcome more time with his four children and 17 grandchildren, while Huffmon noted that Norman has previously discussed finding other ways to influence conservative politics. 

Norman suggested Tuesday that whatever comes next may take him outside elected office. He said he still wants to help South Carolina and believes “something good” will come from the loss, even if he does not yet know what that will be.

“My role may be in something else,” Norman said. “It won’t be in the political arena.”

Read more ‘Truly Trump country.’ Political muscle decisive for Graham’s victory in SC

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *