A South Carolina man who claims he is wrongly accused of killing a Rock Hill teen despite prosecutors claiming he is seen on video allegedly firing a shotgun into a house before going back and killing her, has agreed to a mental evaluation.
Read more A family celebration ended in a fatal stabbing. What happened next?
Sean Xavier Hubbard, 35, is charged with murder in the May death of Camariya Tidwell, 19. He also faces two counts of shooting into a dwelling and two weapons charges.
Tuesday, in a short York County court hearing in front of Judge Eugene Griffith covered exclusively by The Herald, Hubbard’s lawyer, Phil Smith of the York County Public Defender’s Office said Hubbard agreed to have the evaluation before prosecutors can call the case to trial.
Those evaluations typically are done to determine if a defendant is competent to stand trial and assist in his own defense.
Hubbard also agreed to allow his family to see the evidence prosecutors have that he previously declined to let them see, according to Smith.
Prosecutors: 4 videos of Hubbard the day of the killing
Hubbard denies involvement despite prosecutor Hannah Woods claiming in a previous hearing that there are four videos of Hubbard on the day of the crime.
The videos include a doorbell camera recording — widely circulated online after the killing — that authorities claim shows Hubbard firing a shotgun in broad daylight at the home.
He was then allegedly captured on video creeping into the front yard later that night and leaving the scene after Tidwell was killed, according to Woods. Still another video allegedly shows Hubbard on his parents’ house Ring camera returning with the murder weapon while wearing the same clothes as at the time of the killing, Woods said.
Read more Haiti gang releases 6-year-old U.S. citizen five months after kidnapping
Police said when Hubbard was arrested that Tidwell was not believed to be the intended target in the shootings, but other details about a motive for why Hubbard allegedly attacked the house with a shotgun and then returned and killed Tidwell have been released in court.
Hubbard denies the killing, claims he was in NC all day
Hubbard has previously refused to be tested for mental capacity, tried to fire his court-appointed lawyer, and claimed in court the case against him should be dropped. He alleges that a typographical error on a police document in the case is grounds to dismiss all charges, as well as claiming that his arrest is mistaken identity.
Hubbard did not speak in court Tuesday. But two weeks ago, he told Judge Griffith; “I’m still waiting on my reason to be here. Someone with the wrong identity, you can’t go forward with any process.”
He also claimed in an earlier court hearing this summer that he was 70 miles away in Albemarle, N.C. at the time of the shooting into the house and the murder.
“I guess my point was I know my whereabouts and where I was and actually what I’ve done,” Hubbard told a judge in August.
What happens now?
It remains unclear how long a mental evaluation by state officials will take. The Herald has covered cases where evaluations can take months.
Hubbard was arrested at his parents home near Lake Wylie hours after Tidwell was shot to death and has been jailed without bail ever since.
Read more South Carolina Election Day is here. Here’s what to know about statewide and school board races
He faces as much as life in prison if convicted of murder.
